Most lender liability in private loans does not arise from the decision to lend. It arises from conduct during the loan: how terms were negotiated, how variations were handled, and how security was enforced. A private lender can drive a hard bargain and still act lawfully. The difficulty is knowing where commercial pressure stops being defensible. Reported decisions give some markers.
Three areas repay attention: the statutory duty on a controller selling secured property, the unfair contract terms regime, and unconscionable conduct. Each turns on the facts. Each is shaped, for better or worse, by the lender’s own records.
Enforcement: the s 420A duty and the Manda decision
Where the borrower is a corporation and the lender appoints a controller, s 420A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) applies to a sale of the property. The controller must take all reasonable care to sell the property for not less than its market value, or, where it has no market value, for the best price reasonably obtainable in the circumstances.
The wording matters. The duty is one of reasonable care, not a guarantee of the best possible price. A court will not measure the outcome against a hypothetical sale that never happened.
The Victorian Supreme Court applied the section in Manda Capital Holdings Pty Ltd v PEC Portfolio Springvale Pty Ltd [2022] VSC 381. The mortgagee sold a development site after Melbourne’s second COVID-19 lockdown in 2020. The borrower admitted default and the debt, but counterclaimed under s 420A. Its expert valued the property retrospectively at $7.8 million, as at December 2020 and March 2021. The court dismissed the counterclaim.
Two features of the reasoning are useful to lenders. First, the court assessed the sale as a whole rather than isolating individual steps. It adopted the approach in Boz One Pty Ltd v McLellan [2015] VSCA 68, which looks at the circumstances the controller actually faced at the time. Second, the court found a four-week expression-of-interest campaign “entirely adequate, if not best practice”. The agents were experienced inner-Melbourne development site agents, the campaign drew considerable interest, and the process was documented.
The practical lesson is that a mortgagee’s defence is built before the counterclaim arrives. Agent-led campaigns, a recorded rationale for each step, and contemporaneous evidence of market testing do the work. A retrospective valuation obtained for litigation is a common tactic, and it is difficult to run against a well-documented sale.
One qualification: s 420A applies to a “controller” of a corporation’s property. Whether it applies to every mortgagee, and how it sits alongside general law duties, depends on the structure. That is worth checking at the point of enforcement rather than after.
Documentation: the unfair contract terms regime
From 9 November 2023, unfair contract terms became illegal and attract substantial penalties under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and the ASIC Act 2001 (Cth). Each unfair term is a separate contravention. ASIC’s commencement notice confirms the change and the penalty exposure.
The regime targets standard-form contracts with small businesses. Several features of a private lender’s standard documentation are the usual candidates: broad unilateral variation rights, wide discretions to call a default, indemnities that shift risk regardless of fault, and termination clauses that operate one way only. Commentary from Dentons on the reforms notes that penalties can reach $50 million for a corporate contravention, with individuals also exposed.
Whether the regime reaches a particular private lender depends on several questions. Is the borrower a small business within the statutory thresholds? Is the contract standard-form? Is the loan a financial product or service for the purposes of the ASIC Act? Those questions need to be worked through against the current statute, not assumed either way.
Two points follow for lenders who run a book of commercial loans. First, standard-form documents should be reviewed with the regime in mind, particularly clauses that give the lender a discretion without any corresponding constraint. Second, even where the regime does not apply, the same clauses are evidence of how the lender behaves. They will be read in any later dispute, whatever the statutory position.
The way security is layered matters here too. Where a mezzanine lender sits behind a senior facility, the lender’s rights on default are shaped by the intercreditor arrangements with the senior lender. A term that reads as a broad discretion in the loan agreement may be constrained by a standstill provision elsewhere. Inconsistency between the two documents is a gift to a borrower looking for a claim.
Conduct: unconscionability and the Stubbings litigation
Unconscionable conduct is the least predictable source of exposure, and the Stubbings litigation shows why. The proceeding concerned a non-bank, asset-backed loan. The borrower’s indebtedness was found at first instance in the Victorian Supreme Court to have been procured by unconscionable conduct. The Victorian Court of Appeal overturned that finding. The High Court then unanimously held that the lenders had acted unconscionably: Stubbings v Jams 2 Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 6.
The different outcomes at each level are the point. Unconscionability turns on the borrower’s circumstances and the lender’s knowledge of them. Where a borrower lacks commercial understanding and plainly cannot repay from income, a loan that depends entirely on the value of the security carries risk for the lender. A guarantee taken in those circumstances is exposed in the same way. Commentary on the decision has framed it as the High Court preferring substance over form, and that reading is consistent with the outcome.
For private lenders, the lesson is not that asset-based lending is unsafe. It is that the file should show the lender turned its mind to capacity and to the borrower’s understanding of the transaction. A documented assessment, a record of advice given to a guarantor, and evidence that the borrower understood the terms are all useful. The absence of those records is what a claimant will point to.
Where commercial judgment ends
The line is not drawn between tough and generous dealing. It is drawn between conduct that can be explained and conduct that cannot. A lender who calls a default early, refuses a variation, or sells a property quickly may be entirely within its rights. The same lender is exposed if the file shows no reason for the decision, no consideration of alternatives, or no record of what the borrower was told.
Three practices follow from the decisions above.
- Record the why, not just the what. Courts assess enforcement conduct as a whole. A short file note explaining why a campaign was run over four weeks rather than eight, or why a variation was declined, is worth more than a longer document written after the dispute begins.
- Keep documentation consistent across the structure. Loan agreements, intercreditor deeds and security documents should not give the lender rights in one place that another document removes. Subordinated structures are where this goes wrong most often.
- Review standard terms against the current regime. The UCT reforms changed the consequences of one-sided drafting. The review is not a one-off exercise, and it should cover guarantees and variations, not only the primary facility.
None of this removes commercial judgment from lending. It records it. That record is what separates a decision a court will accept from one it will not.
Where a transaction involves subordinated security, a borrower with limited commercial background, or enforcement in a soft market, the time to test the position is before the loan settles. For related issues in asset-based transactions, see our analysis of no-doc commercial lending in Victoria, and on borrower-side insolvency events, director penalty notices and private lending.
Book an appointment with one of our Lawyers to discuss your specific needs.
Book a ConsultationA Note on the Information We Share
Reading this information does not create a lawyer-client relationship between you and SLK Lawyers. This only occurs with a formal written agreement. Content is current at publication and applies to Victorian law unless stated otherwise. It is general information only and not a substitute for specific legal advice. Strict time limits apply to legal claims. You should seek immediate legal advice on your specific situation to ensure your rights are protected.